THE BEST PIZZA IN NEW HAVEN
Order Your Favorites for fast take-out or Delivery
From our family to your table for over 30+ years. Enjoy classic New Haven style pies and our signature white clam apizza made to order. Get the lowest prices on your favorites by choosing carry-out at checkout.
Office Lunch · Game Day · Birthday
Ready-to-go packages for groups of 10-50. Cheaper, faster, and guaranteed compared to ordering one by one.
Tax-exempt orders for 501(c)(3)
Schools, universities, churches and charitable orgs — we waive sales tax once your IRS status is verified.
Browse the menu
See full menuCreate an account
Order faster next time.
- Your address stays saved
- No text code on every order
- Your points add up
New Haven's Best Sellers
The dishes our neighbors keep coming back for — hand-tossed, charred, made fresh.
Pizza Plus Special Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, mushrooms, onions and peppers over signature sauce on a charred thin crust.
The White Clam Pie
Baby clams, olive oil, garlic, oregano and Pecorino Romano — no tomato sauce — on a charred thin crust.
The Clam Casino Pie
Baby clams, smoked bacon, garlic and Pecorino Romano on a crispy, lightly charred thin crust.
Buffalo Wings
Never-frozen wings fried golden and tossed in our rich, buttery buffalo sauce. Bleu cheese or ranch on the side.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken over crisp romaine with garlic croutons and Pecorino Romano, Caesar dressing on the side.
Meatball Parmigiana Grinder
Italian meatballs in rich marinara on toasted bread with melted mozzarella.
Bacon Cheeseburger
All-beef patty with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a toasted hard roll.
Chicken Alfredo
Grilled chicken over penne in our velvety house-made Alfredo of cream, garlic, butter and Pecorino.
Pasta Bolognese
Slow-simmered ragù of ground beef, onions and carrots over pasta, finished with Pecorino Romano.
New England Clam Chowder
Plump chopped clams and tender Yukon potatoes in a rich, creamy broth.
NY-Style Cheesecake
Classic New York-style cheesecake finished with a sweet strawberry topping.
Strawberry Banana Milkshake
Thick and creamy, blended with real strawberry and banana.
What the neighborhood says
Real reviews from our Google customers.
Just ordered the Pizza Plus gourmet meat pizza and the Melted Grilled Chicken sub. Tasted both and it was excellent. Nice and hot and delivered by a cheerful driver. Very seldom you see both at the same time. Thanks Pizza Plus.
Chicken Alfredo hit the spot — y'all gotta give these folks a try. I also had wings but they got devoured upon receiving.
The pizza is really good, taste fantastic. I think it's the best pizza place in Fair Haven hands down. I just started ordering last week and made my second order today. And the guy that answers the phone seems really nice.
Just ordered the Pizza Plus gourmet meat pizza and the Melted Grilled Chicken sub. Tasted both and it was excellent. Nice and hot and delivered by a cheerful driver. Very seldom you see both at the same time. Thanks Pizza Plus.
Chicken Alfredo hit the spot — y'all gotta give these folks a try. I also had wings but they got devoured upon receiving.
The pizza is really good, taste fantastic. I think it's the best pizza place in Fair Haven hands down. I just started ordering last week and made my second order today. And the guy that answers the phone seems really nice.
Each time that I have ordered from Pizza Plus (Grand Avenue) the food has been delicious and reasonably priced, the staff is friendly and always ready to help, and the food is delivered hot and in a timely manner by courteous delivery.
The driver was very courteous. The food was hot and very good. I ordered beef empanadas and french fries. The prices were reasonable.
Great little place with everything you could want. Very polite employees and awesome prices.
Each time that I have ordered from Pizza Plus (Grand Avenue) the food has been delicious and reasonably priced, the staff is friendly and always ready to help, and the food is delivered hot and in a timely manner by courteous delivery.
The driver was very courteous. The food was hot and very good. I ordered beef empanadas and french fries. The prices were reasonable.
Great little place with everything you could want. Very polite employees and awesome prices.
Affordable and very delicious. I love the sauce.
Good food, fast delivery.
Great pizza and appetizers.
Affordable and very delicious. I love the sauce.
Good food, fast delivery.
Great pizza and appetizers.
Very good pizza!
Nice family run place.
Nice people, great pizza.
Very good pizza!
Nice family run place.
Nice people, great pizza.
Pizza Plus has anchored the Fair Haven neighborhood with family-crafted takeout and delivery since 1990.
For over three decades, Pizza Plus has stood as a proud staple of the Fair Haven community. Since opening our doors in 1990, our family-owned and operated pizzeria has focused on one simple mission: baking incredible pizza for our neighbors to enjoy at home. Over the past 35 years, many dedicated employees have come and gone, each leaving their mark on our history. Through every season of change, our family has remained right here at the heart of the business, personally crafting every pie and serving the community we love. We do not do table service or shortcuts—just authentic, high-quality pizza made with fresh ingredients and time-honored family recipes.
As we look toward the future, our deep gratitude belongs entirely to the generations of Fair Haven families who have made us a part of their weekly routines. We have watched children who used to come in with their parents now ordering pies for their own kids. Pizza Plus is proud to be the fuel for local Friday night football games, moving days, birthday parties, and late-night study sessions. Thank you for welcoming our family into your homes for over 35 years, and we look forward to keeping the tradition alive for many more.
Frequently asked questions
Quick answers about delivery, hours, dietary options, and how Pizza Plus works.